Broadway Diner's Pie Shop
The Best Pies in Columbia, MO
We make each pie from scratch with real ingredients, ensuring every bite is perfect.
Welcome to Broadway Diner's Pie Shop, your go-to for pies in Columbia, MO. We make each pie from scratch with real ingredients, ensuring every bite is perfect.
Ordering is easy. Browse our selection, choose your pies, and call us to place your order.
Thank you for choosing Broadway Diner's Pie Shop. We look forward to baking something special for you!
Our delicious pies are 10" and serve 8.
Pie Menu
Baked From Scratch, Every Day
Jasper Pie
Apple Pie
Cherry Pie
Pumpkin Pie
Peach Pie
Pecan Pie
Key Lime Pie
Elvis Pie
Truman Pie
Strawberry Pie
Chocolate Pie
Butterscotch Pie
Texas Sheet Cake (Half Sheet Pan)
Gooey Butter Cake (Half Sheet Pan)
Ready to Order?
Order Your Pies in Advance
Call ahead and we’ll have them ready.
All of our 10" pies are $30. Our half-sheet pans of Gooey Butter Cake and Texas Cake are $25. Stop in for a $4 slice of pie at the diner.
Good to Know
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I place an order for a pie?
Give us a call at (573) 875-1173 to place your pie order. Let us know which pies you’d like and your pickup day, and we’ll take care of the rest.
What are the prices?
All of our 10" pies are $30. Our half-sheet pans of Gooey Butter Cake and Texas Cake are $25. Stop in for a $4 slice of pie at the diner.
Can I pay for my order online?
Currently, we do not accept online payments. After placing your order, please visit us at The Broadway Diner or call us to arrange payment.
What are the available pickup times?
You can pick up your pies Monday to Thursday between 6am and 1pm. Special exceptions can be made upon request by contacting us directly.
What pies do you offer?
We offer a variety of pies, including Jasper, Apple, Cherry, Pumpkin, Peach, Pecan, Elvis, Truman, Strawberry Rhubarb (when in season), and half sheet pans of Texas Sheet Cake and Gooey Butter Cake. All pies are 10 inches and made from scratch with real ingredients.
How do I know my order has been placed successfully?
Once you submit your order, you will see a confirmation message on the website. Additionally, you will receive a confirmation email with the details of your order and the pickup information.
Can I change or cancel my order after placing it?
If you need to make changes or cancel your order, please contact us as soon as possible. We will do our best to accommodate your request.
What if I can't pick up my pies on the scheduled date?
It is important to pick up your pies on the specified date as they will not be held for a later pickup. Please contact us if you foresee any issues with your pickup time.
Do you offer any gluten-free or vegan options?
At this time, we do not offer gluten-free or vegan pies. All our pies are made with traditional ingredients.
Where do I pick up my pies?
Pies can be picked up at The Broadway Diner, located at 22 S. Fourth Street, Columbia, MO.